close
close

The boos of the polls from the stands will resonate in the ears of the Government

Analysis: The three coalition leaders have a lot to ponder after a poll spoiler, writes political editor Maiki Sherman.

The Prime Minister will feel the pressure of political office this week.

Christopher Luxon, who is openly competitive by nature, will absolutely hate his Government’s latest scorecard. The public has booed loudly from the stands while voters indicate that little by little they are losing faith.

For a coalition that has only been in government for five months, such hissing from the electorate is nothing short of devastating.

The latest 1News Verian poll suggests National, ACT and NZ First would be out of power if an election were held now. In fact, Winston Peters and his entire group would be exiled from Parliament once again.

It is difficult to think of a worse outcome for a first-term government so soon after being elected.

John Key’s government in 2015 and Helen Clark’s government in 2006 had similar poll results, but both were third-term governments at the time.

It would be easy to blame the result of this latest poll entirely on the fact that NZ First did not meet the 5% threshold. It would be equally easy to dismiss the figures as nothing more than a one-off.

Doing either would be a mistake.

Victims of a negative vibe?

Christopher Luxon's personal popularity as preferred prime minister has fallen.

None of the three ruling parties has much to be happy about in this survey. It will take the leaders of all three parties to ensure that their mandate as a credible government does not crumble.

The National Party has fallen two points and, in turn, has ceded crucial ground to the Labor Party, who, having been in the political wilderness, has re-emerged in the more respectable 1930s. But this is very much a case in which the National Party loses support rather than the Labor Party regaining it.

Luxon’s personal popularity as preferred Prime Minister has also fallen two points.

This is despite the fact that his own social media presence has accelerated. While many voters will be fans of a more personal take on Luxon, you’ll soon learn that there’s no substitute for substance. The Prime Minister cannot escape the negative headlines with TikTok.

The Government has implemented a ton of policies to date. But the general vibe is negative. In its first 100 days, much of the coalition’s work involved scrapping and reversing initiatives from the previous Labor government.

When it finally came time to focus on the government’s own agenda, the vision was much the same bleak: crack down on recipients, reduce rules for receiving disability payments, potentially reduce free school lunches, resurrect Three Strikes legislation, going after gangs with a patch ban proposal and a controversial fast-track bill moving through a select committee.

All of these issues are inherently negative and force the Prime Minister to spend much of his air time and capital defending these positions.

It is debatable whether those policies will have a significant impact on the country as a whole. Meanwhile, they further isolate specific parts of our communities.

A pessimistic perspective

The latest 1News Verian poll is disastrous for New Zealand First, which, according to the figures, would be left out of Parliament.

However, it is not so much that the electorate does not support a tougher approach: many voters will support it. The problem is rather that voters have been given nothing to look forward to.

At a time when people are having a hard time with the overwhelming cost of living, voters want to feel inspired and encouraged.

The constant deficit mentality is a mass of rumors. The current narrative focuses too much on punching and asking everyone to do more with less.

Voters can’t even expect a tax cut without nearly every economist in the country warning that now is not the right time.

When it comes to the economic outlook, an area where National often offers reassurance to voters, the 1News Verian poll shows a 7% rise in those who think our financial situation will get worse.

Overall, this is a depressing reality that the Government itself is now forced to confront.

While the coalition may be right about the long-term benefits, it will need to do more to convince the electorate of the same sacrifice. Failure to do so risks further riots.

Culture war fatigue?

Winston Peters would do well to be as strategic locally as he is globally, writes Maiki Sherman

And we haven’t even mentioned the words race or Māori yet. But that could also cause problems in the polls for National’s coalition partners.

Voters are likely to be tired of the continuing culture war, the latest installment being NZ First and ACT uniting against the Waitangi Tribunal and the Māori Land Court.

Peters also created a political sandstorm when he compared alleged Te Pāti Māori comments about superior DNA to what was seen in Nazi Germany.

Peters’ comments generated controversial headlines both here and abroad. While that policy may have paid off for NZ First during the election campaign, as a ruling party and deputy prime minister, it could be considered reckless and unnecessary.

Peters likes to remind the media that he “won” the battle, returning his party to Parliament and public favour. But such outbursts can only risk losing the war. That war, which is largely internal, is ensuring that Peters and his party do not implode and end up outside Parliament again after one term in government, a fate not unknown to NZ First.

So far, Peters has defied critics who warned he would be the bane of any coalition. On the contrary, he appears to be working with reliable integrity.

He has also worked better than most at the Cabinet table through a grueling overseas schedule that has largely been successful.

But as one notable political commentator has already pointed out, Winston Peters, the global statesman, is not entirely the same as Winston Peters, the despised political leader.

Peters’ contempt for the media (and for Labour, for that matter) is the hangover that just won’t go away. You would do well to be as strategic locally as you are globally.

A complicated transition

David Seymour appears to still be transitioning from opposition to government

Meanwhile, David Seymour finds himself in much the same situation.

He is a political leader who has not yet made the transition from opposition to government.

During the election campaign, there was a change in the behavior of the ACT Party leader. His days as a happy-go-lucky and charismatic opposition MP have faded somewhat into a more irritable and less tolerant government minister.

Seymour has allowed himself to be distracted by petty politics, sometimes attacking preemptively and almost always unnecessarily.

It’s behavior that has recently seen him accused of undermining Christopher Luxon, or vice versa, depending on who you ask.

However, public discussions between coalition partners can never be a good thing. It is even more worrying when it comes to the Prime Minister.